BJ's New York Gas Prices
Find the cheapest BJ's gas in New York— every gas station ranked by today's price.
29 BJ's gas stations in 28 cities · 11 of 29 sell diesel
BJ's operates 29 gas stations in New York across 28 cities, with the largest cluster in Rochester (2 stations). Across the state, regular gas averages $4.112, premium runs about $0.78 higher at $4.893, and diesel sits at $5.317. The lowest-priced regular pump is at BJ's Bellport - Brookhaven in Bellport at $3.759, while Oneonta in Oneonta sits about $0.71 higher. Diesel is sold at 11 of the 29 New York locations.
If your vehicle takes premium, the lowest in New York is BJ's Farmingdale in Farmingdale at $4.499. The cheapest diesel is at BJ's Commack in Commack at $5.099. Pump prices shift from one club to the next with local taxes, fuel-blend rules, and transport costs, but BJ's Gas is a membership perk that usually undercuts nearby branded stations — which is what keeps these pumps busy.
30-day New York average price trend
Browse New York cities
All New York stations by price
| Station | Regular | Premium |
|---|---|---|
| Bellport - Brookhaven Bellport | $3.759 | $4.559 |
| Commack Commack | $3.899 | $4.599 |
| Canarsie Brooklyn | $3.919 | $4.679 |
| Freeport Freeport | $3.919 | $4.719 |
| Valley Stream Valley Stream | $3.939 | $4.619 |
| Farmingdale Farmingdale | $3.949 | $4.499 |
| Henrietta Rochester | $3.959 | $4.799 |
| Riverhead Riverhead | $3.959 | $4.799 |
| Hamburg Blasdell | $4.019 | $4.829 |
| Greece Rochester | $4.059 | $4.899 |
Frequently asked questions
Which BJ's has the cheapest gas in New York?
As of the latest update, BJ's Bellport - Brookhaven in Bellport has the cheapest regular gas in New York at $3.759 per gallon. Pump prices change daily, so check the ranking on this page for the current order.
How much is BJ's gas in New York right now?
Across the 29 BJ's gas stations in New York, regular averages $4.112 per gallon, premium $4.893, and diesel $5.317. Those are averages of the latest pump prices — individual stations vary, so see the per-station table on this page.
Does BJ's sell diesel in New York?
Yes — 11 of the 29 BJ's gas stations in New York sell diesel, averaging $5.317 per gallon. Availability varies by club, so check the table above first.
Is BJ's gas in New York cheaper than average?
New York BJ's regular averages $4.112, about $0.39 higher than the chain-wide BJ's average of $3.723. Wherever you fill up, BJ's Gas is usually priced below nearby branded stations.
Do you need a BJ's membership to buy gas in New York?
BJ's Gas in New York is a member benefit — you scan a BJ's membership card at the pump before fueling. Club+ members get an extra 5¢ off per gallon, and BJ's One Mastercard holders can stack additional per-gallon savings.
How do you pay for gas at BJ's in New York?
BJ's gas stations in New York take all major credit and debit cards — Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express — plus BJ's gift cards. The pumps are self-serve and card-operated, and the BJ's One Mastercard earns extra savings on every gallon.
What time do BJ's gas stations open in New York?
Hours vary by location, and the gas station usually opens earlier than the club itself. For example, the pumps at BJ's Bellport - Brookhaven run 6:30AM – 10PM Monday through Saturday. Check the individual station page for exact hours before a long drive.